This post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure here.
These marshmallow chicks turned out delicious. However, they are not the easiest recipe. There is a bit of candy-making technique involved, and you’re going to need some special tools: candy thermometer, stand mixer, piping bag, tips, and patience. Are they worth it? Eh. If you REALLY want marshmallow chicks and refuse to buy the kind in stores, yes. If you want a fun project with the kids, sure. I won’t make these often, but I don’t mind the effort once a year.
The bright yellow, store-bought, marshmallow chicks are made with sugar, corn syrup, gelatin, yellow #5, potassium sorbate (preservative), natural flavors, and carnauba wax. Our homemade version will leave out the corn syrup, food dyes, preservatives, synthetic flavors, and wax. So, yes, it’s all sugar and gelatin. If you’re vegetarian, you’re out of luck. Marshmallows rely on gelatin which is made from animals. The gelatin used to make the store-bought chicks is derived from the pork industry and gets a bad rap for being very inhumane
The good news? One of the benefits to making marshmallows at home is quality control over your ingredients. There are more humane gelatin options, and that’s what I used. I found a Kosher, all natural, grass-fed cow-derived gelatin (pictured). This stuff is awesome. Chuck out the stuff in your pantry and replace it. It’s 88-92% pure protein and has an amazing amino acid profile. Yes, it smells like ponies as you cook it, but the smell goes away and doesn’t transfer to the food.
-Yes, you need a candy thermometer. It’s the difference between firm marshmallows and soft fluff. Test your thermometer in boiling water for accuracy. Mine was off by 8º.
-98% of all marshmallow recipes require corn syrup. Why? It’s actually a logical addition: corn syrup prevents crystallization of the sugar, guaranteeing a smooth, fluffy texture. Without it, the marshmallow may get grainy over time as the sugars crystallize again. I left it out, because I know these chicks won’t make it more than a couple days in my house.
-I used plain, uncolored sugar for my chicks. You can use a colored sugar. I’ve seen all natural food dyes and sugars at Whole Foods, $7-20. There are some good DIY recipes online, though. I made a green sugar using chlorophyll that I had on hand.
-The kids LOVED this project. They wanted to pipe the chicks, sugar them, paint eyeballs on them, and they loved eating them.
-This project requires a good bit of space. I moved to my kitchen table for the piping.
-I’m not remotely talented with a pastry bag. Yes, you have permission laugh at my lumpy little marshmallow birds. I know they’re an eyesore, but that’s as good as I could get! If you make some with better results (or comical results), please share!
-Any piping tips from more experienced people?
Store Bought Easter Treats without Junk?
Don’t have time to home make your own Easter treats? There are plenty of candy options you can still buy without junky ingredients! Here are a few that may end up in our Easter baskets this year:
-Annie’s Organic Gummy Bunnies
-Justin’s Nut Butter Peanut Butter Cups
-Surf Sweets gummy treats
-Yummy Earth Organics Lollipops and Gummy Bears
-Green & Black’s Organic Chocolate Bars (I might melt down a few of these and mold our own chocolate bunnies!)
Do you have any more ideas to share? What about non-candy ideas?
Candy is candy. We’re not trying to make it a health food. What we do want is something more natural, not a bunch of preservatives, synthetic ingredients, and cost-cutting additives. These special candies are around just once a year. If you love these store-bought treats, contact the manufacturer and kindly ask them to produce a more natural version. Maybe some dye-free Peeps? Certified non-GMO Peeps? Reese’s Eggs without PGPR or hydrogenated oils? Let them know what you’d like. Who knows? They might start to listen. In the meantime, make your own treats. You’ll cut out the synthetic ingredients, genetically modified foods, and preservatives. By using organic sugar, you’re also reducing the glycemic load (45 in organic sugar vs. 85 in refined white sugar). How would you remake your favorite candy?
The following is part of an Organic Living Journey Guest Post Series now written by Mariana who has a mother’s heart and scientist’s brain. Check out Easter Treats Without the Junk, Part I to see how Mariana makes homemade chocolate covered peanut butter eggs!