Welcome to Southern Savers, where finding deals and steals is simple and rewarding!

See I told you, this would help!

Coupon Abbreviations
  • SC = Store Coupon
  • MC = Manufacturer Coupon
  • SS = Smart Source
  • RP = Red Plum
  • PG = Proctor and Gamble
Coupon Terms
  • WYB = When You Buy
  • B1G1 = Buy One Get One Free
  • .75/1 = 75 cents off one item
  • .75/3 = 75 cents off three items
  • EXP = Expiration Date

Going Nuts? I can help you understand coupon terms and abbreviations

This post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure here.

The holidays are just around the corner and I’m already thinking about all of the food that I need to prepare.  I have a long list of dishes that “need” to be on the table for everyone to feel like it’s Thanksgiving.  If you miss one of those dishes… then you just ruined the day.  No pressure…

My trick to help relieve a bit of that pressure is to go pre-made on some things.  To me, it’s tastier and easier for me to buy a pre-made pie rather than slave over one along with the millions of other dishes.  My go-to pies every season are Mrs. Smith’s® and Edwards®.


First off, let me just say these aren’t gluten free.  My husband has to watch the rest of us eat these.  This is where I probably could use more empathy… but I just can’t pass up buttery flaky crusts and the  amazing crumbly dutch topping on an Apple Pie.  Mrs. Smith’s®  has lots of fruit-filled pies to choose from and I just wish I could have them all.


Edwards® pies are another nice, cool treat.  This is the favorite of my kids.  I know the box says to thaw before serving, but I confess we eat this like decadent ice cream right out of the freezer.

If you’re looking to cut some corners on holiday desserts, run to the store and pick up Mrs. Smith’s® and Edwardss®.  Throw away the box and no one will know it’s home made (I promise, I won’t tell).

The best news is that you can save right now with a $1.00 off coupon for any Mrs. Smith’s® or Edwards® whole pie.

The Giveaway:

5 Southern Savers readers will win a $50 Walmart gift card.

To Enter:

Watch both videos on the Walmart website and leave a comment below telling me which pie your family will love the MOST for the upcoming holidays!

The winner of this giveaway will be chosen and posted to the Giveaway Winners page Wednesday, November 13th and posted to the Giveaway Winners Page.

This giveaway is sponsored by MRS. SMITH’S® or EDWARDS® but all opinions are 100% my own.

NO PURCHASE OR PAYMENT OF ANY KIND NECESSARY, A PURCHASE OR PAYMENT WILL NOT INCREASE YOUR CHANCES OF WINNING. The Giveaway starts on 11/6/13 and ends on 11/13/13. Click on Official Rules for details on entry instructions, odds of winning, prize details, restrictions, etc. Open only to legal residents of the 50 U.S./D.C. and 18 years or older as of time of entry. Residents of P.R. are ineligible. Void in P.R. and where prohibited. Sponsor: The Schwan Food Company, 115 West College Drive, Marshall, MN 56258 (View full rules and regulations.)


    • jrickerhagler

      The apple crumble one…. yummy:)

    • jrickerhagler

      The apple crumble one…. yummy:)

    • Kathie S

      We love pumpkin!

    • Kathie S

      We love pumpkin!

    • Elizabeth Jacobson

      My family would LOVE the apple pie the most. My father used to make his “famous” apple pie for thanksgiving, and the smell drove the whole family crazy! My mom tries her best to make it every year to remember him by, but it’s just not my fathers. The reason I love Mrs Smiths apple pie is because it almost matches the deliciousness of his. It’s like thanksgiving happiness and memories anytime of the year.

    • We would absolutely LOVE that Hershey’s Crème Pie!! Oh my goodness, it sounds heavenly!

    • kc

      apple pie

    • miatd

      the apple flakey pie for sure

    • latanya t

      the key lime pie

    • Heather

      The Edwards Hersey Creme Pie. It looks amazing and we love chocolate.

    • theaikenparrs

      The apple pie would be the biggest hit at our house!

    • Rachel

      Hershey’s Creme Pie

    • Nikki Lovins

      Oh my that apple pie looks oh so so delicious!! I am a mother a five and new to couponing…EKKKKK!! I am actually doing my first shopping trip tonight. We have hit a very rough spot with me working as a CNA and deciding to go back to school to finish my nursing degree. Anyhow I still have to plan for thanksgiving and christmas dinner! They kids would drool all over the Hersheys pie, But who can have thanksgiving without a delicious Apple and Pumkin pie!! All the memories growing up of having more cool whip on my plate than pie, because I didnt relize the yummy goodness I was missing!! Gotta go with that apple pie for sure! Although my kids would disagree :)

    • Christine M

      Heshey creme pie my kids would LOVE that!

    • Richard McInnes

      hershey creme pie

    • Aymee

      Hershey’s pie by far!!!!!!!!!!

    • anntaylor

      My family would love the Key Lime Pie the most…..It’s so Yummy!!

    • smel111

      Hershey’s Creme Pie. Yumm.

      I have to buy single servings, to keep from over indulging.

    • Cathy

      Definitely Apple pie!

    • megan

      hershey creme pie! yum!

    • Amy Williams

      Hershey Pie for sure!

    • Chrissy

      We love Key Lime Pie, but the Apple Pie in the video looks amazing!!!

    • Stephanie Covil Carter

      Key Lime pie is the favorite here!

    • Summer Chesshir

      We love the turtle, cherry, pumpkin,and apple crumble pies. They’re all so good. We’d love to try the Hershey’s Crème Pie!

    • asgcoach

      Hershey’s cookie one looks delicious as does the apple pie…

    • Shawnee Johnson

      Gotta love the apple pie. Classic!

    • Gayle Porter

      We will be having the Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie and the Edward’s Lemon Pie. My favorite is the Edward’s Lemon Pie! Awesome goodness!

    • staci

      Key Lime!

    • JessieC

      We would love Mrs Smith’s flaky crust pumpkin pie.

    • CarlaJo Gray

      We love the Herseys! Homemade doesn’t taste any better than this.

    • Deborah

      My husband thinks there is nothing better than a Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie but I prefer the Edwards Hersheys pie! Guess we’ll have to get one of each.

    • tuckyblue2

      yum key lime pie and pumpkin

    • erinisgett

      I don’t think we’ve had one of those pies that we didn’t love! The apple pie is always a favorite here :)

    • Kim Trombly

      Mrs. Smith’s pumpkin!

    • Kim Trombly

      Mrs. Smith’s pumpkin!

    • Kim Trombly

      Mrs. Smith’s pumpkin!

    • Abby Schiera

      My family would love the Mrs. Smith’s Pumpkin Pie! I never even knew that I liked pumpkin pie until I went vegetarian and finally decided “what the heck I will try it” and I loved it!

    • Joanna

      Apple for me a
      That is my favorite

    • peggy

      We would love the apple pie with some vanilla ice cream on the side, yummy !

    • Edwards makes a delicious Key Lime Pie, one of my favorites!

    • wondering

      gotta be chocolate creme pie!

    • Kris

      The apple pie is our tradition; but the kids would love the Hershey’s.

    • Rosemary

      Husband loves the apple pie.

    • KimR

      OMG!!! They all are so good, but my absolute favorite is the Edwards Chocolate Creme Pie…the best. And now I can’t try it frozen like you said Jen!

    • Samantha Tim Steed

      Mrs. Smith’s Pumpkin pie is our all time favorite but so is the Apple pie..especially with vanilla bean ice cream..YUM! Tuff choice.. =)

    • disqus_XUEUbT9Pb6

      Both look so delicious, but i’m going with the Edwards chocolate pie.

    • Paula

      The Key Lime is always a hit at our house. We can all agree on that .

    • Kimberly Bowman

      Apple crumble for me and Pumpkin for everyone else. Who buys just one??? They all look great!

    • Dawn Isbell Jones

      Apple with a slice of cheese on it!!!!!!! mmm but frankly would be pleased and thankful for ANY! cause they are ALL amazing!!! not a big cherry fan though hehe

    • Karen

      I love the Southern Pecan Pie and the Pumpkin Pie! Thanksgiving Classics. I can’t wait! :)

    • Bill

      Southern Pecan

    • Noel

      Can’t beat Classic Pumpkin

    • Brittany Whitesel

      Edward’s Hershey’s Creme Pie, for sure! Our family is BIG on anything chocolate. And it looks DELICIOUS!!!

    • Mandi

      Normally, since it’s Thanksgiving, I’d say pecan or apple, but since I’m now drooling over the Hershey’s pie, we’ll say that one!

    • Marcie

      I am a huge fan of apple, nothing beats my mom’s but these look delish

    • Cheryl

      My family will love the Edwards Hershey’s Crème pie but I prefer the lemon ice box pie.

    • Beth

      Definitely Southern Pecan

    • Elizabeth

      Pumpkin is my fav and my hubby loves pecan pie. YUMMY!

    • ajawee83

      Definitely apple

    • Guest

      Pumpkin and the Hershey pie!

    • Leah Altgilbers Fleming

      Pumpkin pie!

    • Kim Henry

      Edward’s Chocolate pie would disappear fast here!

    • Michelle

      Southern Pecan and Pumpkin! I rarely get them, so they are a TREAT for the holidays for sure!

    • lucysullivan

      I love all holiday desserts and these are great options!

    • Janna Beth Butler

      We love the Hershey’s pie!

    • Lisa

      The Edwards Chocolate Pie is what my family would love to have. I am diabetic & don’t eat sweets,but I would still buy it for my family .

    • Crysti L.

      This is a hard one…Apple for the kid, Pumpkin for the husband and Hershey’s special dark for me!

    • Shannon Heisler

      Pumpkin is our favorite. Would be nice to win, as I can’t bake..anything.

    • Becky Davis

      The Hershey’s Creme Pie

    • Sandra

      My family loves the warm apple pie…but I am addicted to pumpkin pie!!

    • Rebecca Barr

      Edward’s Key Lime has always been my family’s favorite, but we have recently had to cut out dairy for my husband and little one, so I love that we can still enjoy Mrs. Smith’s apple pies! That’s what we’re having for my birthday tonight!

    • Kat M.

      Edward’s Turtle Tracks and Hershey’s pie are favorites in my house.

    • Kimberly Nelson

      Can’t wait to have some of Edwards Lemon Meringue Pie…YUM!!!

    • Vickie

      My family would love the Key Lime Pie the most but any of them would be tasty…especially with a spoonful of whipped cream or ice cream!

    • Jen T.

      My family loves Edwards Hershey’s Creme pie! Thank you for the great contest.

    • Lin

      I always go with traditional……Ms. Smiths apple pie

    • Kim

      Key Lime would complement the other desserts that I am planning on making!

    • Cassie P.

      Edward’s Keylime pie is always the go to pie for us!

    • KaraFos

      We are Key Lime lovers at this house!

    • stacey

      Edward’s Hershey would be the best for us for thanksgiving! All of us girls are huge chocolate fans!

    • kristina

      We love apple pie!!

    • ginny

      Well I have to admit I bake my pumpkin from scratch and oh wow would it be nice to take that off my to-do list. I think that one would be yummy.

    • melissa

      mrs.smiths cherry pie and edwards keylime would be delicious!

    • Christy Sandhoff France

      We love the Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie warm with vanilla ice cream. Yum!!!

    • Meggan

      My family including the little one in my belly would enjoy the Mrs. Smith’s warm apple pie the best! How can you go wrong with apple pie and vanilla beam ice-cream? You can’t!

    • Natelie

      Mrs. Smith Apple with vanilla bean ice cream YUM! And Edwards Hershey’s Creme Pie is always a favorite around here.

    • Carmen O

      Edwards pies always! My personal favorite is Lemon Meringue, but the family loves Pecan as well!

    • soundring

      I buy the pumpkin every year and we love it!

    • Elena

      We love apple pie
      elena150980 at yahoo dot com

    • Michele Mackneer Allen

      During the holidays, my family loves the fruit pies, so the Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie with vanilla ice cream on top would definitely be our favorite!!

    • allyg24

      i love the apple pie.

    • Jennifer

      Well, my little girl would want the Edward’s pie and the Hershey’s one is her favorite. My husband and I, on the other hand, would prefer a fruit pie, probably pumpkin, for the holidays. So we would have to go with both pies to satisfy the little one and us. :)

    • Kimberly Rankin

      My family members are great cooks but none of us can bake a pie as good as Mrs. Smith’s or Edwards. In the beginning, we would keep one in the freezer in case the homemade didn’t work out, now we don’t even bother. We just buy a few pies each holiday. My favorite is the Chocolate Pie and I think most of the family would agree with me. Thank you Edwards!

    • mami2jcn

      I would love the pumpkin pie.

    • brandi

      We would love the Apple Pie!

    • keith

      Edwards Hershey Pie and do it the way you said. What a great idea. Then also pumpkin of course.

    • connieb03

      We love Key Lime Pie!!!

    • sandra

      Apple pie warm with vanilla ice cream and maybe pumpkin since its a tradition.

    • Dawn

      Definitely the apple!

    • Rita Ann

      Really anything from Edwards but that Strawberry Creme Pie looks delicious!

    • Barbara

      We love anything apple and this looks delicious and such a flaky crust.

    • Judy

      We LOVE the Salted Caramel Pie:P

    • VP22

      I have to go with the Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie

    • dtcox1

      we love the new choc peanut butter mrs edwards the mrs smiths pecan is always a hit . plus my family is smith

    • Angela Birchfield Farnell

      Salted Caramel

    • Calli

      We really like a lot of them, but I would have to say the Edwards Turtle pie is our favorite!

    • Sydney

      Edwards Key Lime. Yum!

    • Diane

      mrs smiths apple pie! yum!!

    • Jennifer Smith

      Well since I get to choose it will be Edwards Hershey Chocolate pie!

    • Gina

      The Edwards Hershey Pie would and is always a hit at my house.

    • HTaylor

      All these pies from Mrs.Smith’s and Edwards are delicious, but if we had to pick a favorite, it would be the ready to serve Edwards Special Dark Crème Pie!

    • Marilyn

      Mrs. Smith’s apple. We are some apple eating people here in Ga. These pies are so flaky and full of apples.

    • Margaret Lewis

      Edwards Lemon Meringue. My mother made the best, but since she is no longer with us, these are the closest to her’s that I have found.

    • txdakini

      Mrs Smith’s deep dish apple is the best pie in the world. I haven’t been able to find it in the last couple of years, but I bet the flaky apply pie is great too.

    • lilsnap

      Mrs. Smiths Apple and Pumpkin pies. My family is divided. :)

    • Heidi S

      Like you, I also like to buy a Mrs. Smith’s Pumpkin pie and Edwards Oreo pie for Thanksgiving. They don’t last long once they are cut as they are so tasty. Happy Thanksgiving!

    • bryanne davis

      Edwards Hershey chocolate pie would have to be my family’s favorite! My 6 year old asks for this as a birthday cake!

    • esess

      Mrs. Smith’s apple pie…it’s a classic and staple in our home!

    • Cindy

      Edwards Turtle Pie for us!

    • Lisa

      The oreo pie! Oh my gosh – YUM!

    • Jennifer Perry

      Pumpkin pie!

    • Barbara T.

      Edwards Pecan Pie is great. Always get several for the freezer when they go on sale.

    • Jennifer

      The Edwards pecan pie is amazing!

    • cbachmann

      Everyone would love the Hershey’s Creme pie

    • Dana Hackney

      My family always has a Mrs. Smith Dutch Apple for Thanksgiving, though this year I hope my new Mother-In-Law has one, otherwise, I wont get one….

    • Trish S

      We would all love the Hershey’s creme pie!

    • bri garn

      mrs smiths pumpkin pie

    • cm

      Mrs. Smith’s Pumpkin Pie <3

    • Amanda Alford

      Mrs Smith Apple Pie!

    • Kelly


    • Jennifer

      Pumpkin Pie for Thanksgiving!

    • Lisa

      I would love to try the oreo pie.

    • Faith

      Apple Pie

    • kelly

      Hershey’s Crème Pie

    • My family would enjoy the Mrs Smith’s Pumpkin Pie

    • Heather Peterman


    • jen5826

      apple pie

    • Guest1

      We’ll be going with Edwards Strawberry Creme Pie. We haven’t tried this yet but want something alittle different this year for Thanksgiving.

    • Anna Russell

      My husband is 85 years young, and he loves all Edwards pie, but his favorite all year long is the pecan pie. I have diabetes, so I have to watch sugar. I just sit and drool watching him eat and enjoy his pie!!

      • Susie

        Aww, I give Mrs Russell my entry.

        • Anna Russell

          You’re so sweet.

    • dawn

      key lime, mmmm!

    • Kristie Gardner

      We love Edwards pies!! I think our favorite one is the Hershey’s Chocolate creme pie.

    • chester4

      We like pecan.

    • Kiyoko Blue

      The oreo pie is one that the whole family loves!!

    • Heidi Stephens

      The new Hersey’s Cream Pie! Yum! All Edward’s pies are good.

    • Donna

      Key Lime!

    • Amanda Johnson

      Key Lime pie for sure!!

    • Jenn

      Me and my family love Edwards Pies. I think my favorite is the Hersey’s pie :)

    • Rhianna

      Hershey’s Cream Pie sounds DELICIOuS!

    • stickrn

      pumpkin or apple pie!

    • Amber

      pumpkin for sure!

    • Ari0429

      Edward’s key lime!

    • Katherine

      Key lime pie is my favorite!

    • volvosweetie

      Mrs. Smith furit pies are the best.

    • tuemai

      Edward’s Cookies and Creme Pie

    • justiceg

      Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie with a scoop of ice cream and caramel syrup drizzled over it. I’ve served Mrs. Smith’s apple pie “as my own” for years! When the kids come home from college, they beg me to “make” an apple pie (lol)

    • Jessica

      Most defiantly the Hershey’s pie!

    • bullseye1250

      Turtle sounds delicious!

    • esyke623

      As far as Edward’s, the Chocolate pie! For homemade, it has to be pumpkin this time of year!

    • Sarah Landers

      We love the Hershey’s pie!

    • Candace Besse

      The Edward’s Hershey Creme Pie!!

    • sarah

      The chocolate pie or Apple pie. Can’t go wrong with either.

    • Renee

      The Hershey’s Pie looks awesome. I’ll use my coupon to try this one. I will do a test run for Thanksgiving and get it now.

    • Allison

      The Cookies and Cream pie! Yum!

    • wendybinkley

      Pumpkin and apple only way to go for the holidays

    • shaina

      Apple is my favorite! I will be using my coupon on that one for the holidays :)

    • Patty

      Pecan and pumpkin pies would be good right about now.

    • MichelleOU

      For traditional, I love Dutch apple. Non-traditional, Key Lime!

    • Rebecca Johnson Anderson

      I can’t pass up a slice of warm apple pie!

    • Elaine

      Hershey’s pie. YUM!!

    • Donna Osteen

      Hershey’s pie all the way! Thanks for the giveaway!

    • sundrop474

      Definitely pumpkin and pecan for Thanksgiving.

    • SuandChrissy Nguyen-Xiong

      Warm yummy apple pie is what I’m getting tonight!

    • wina

      As for me I love them both, they looked so scrumptious and indulgent, I’ll try them both before the holiday come. But I’m very sure that my husband and our daughter will love Edwards Hersey’s Crème Pie the most, chocolate is their middle name :)

    • lisa smith

      My children beg me to buy them each a whole pie. Of course, after eating Thanksgiving dinner they cant possibly eat a whole pie. Pecan is our treat.

    • Lynn

      Apple AND Pumpkin!!!

    • Jessica

      Hershey’s Pie!

    • vanessa lopez

      apple and pumpkin!!!! I love both!!! yum :)

    • Charity

      The Hershey’s pie looks yummy!

    • Donna

      We here are going to have to go with Mrs. Smith’s Apple and Edward’s Key Lime. thanks

    • Erin

      My son loves key lime and pumpkin so I would choose those.

    • Lynette Nobles

      I LOVE the fruit pies from each brand, but pumpkin is the best at Thanksgiving.

    • Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie hands down!
      heatheranne99 at gmail dot com

    • gccsmom

      My youngest son is crazy about the Key Lime….but I’d like to get ahold of the salted caramel!

    • Laura C Cutshall

      Cookies n’ Cream for me!

    • lovetosave

      It has to be Apple Pie!!!

    • Natasha Brown

      I will buy one for my family also, BUT I will personally be eating an entire Mrs. Smith’s pumpkin pie this year!

    • Tim

      Mrs. Smith’s Cherry Pie!

    • Elizabeth

      I love apple pie!

    • Jessica


    • Debbie H.

      My family goes gaga over that Hershey Pie especially frozen and of course some hot apple pie too!

    • Deanna

      Hersheys and Apple! Yum

    • Betty B.

      Definitely apple!!!

    • Benjamin Tran

      Apple Pie and the Hersheys are amazing! Too bad my family can only get one of the two; or else we’d die of a sugar rush!

    • Melinda Cashwell Bullard

      Edward’s Hershey’s Creme Pie – We love it!

    • brandi

      Hershey’s crème pie!

    • sina

      sweet potato pie with redi whip

    • Gina

      Hershey cream pie

    • lizbister

      Pumpkin pie, of course!

    • Candy

      Mrs. Smith apple and Edwards Hersheys.

    • Rhonda

      My family would definitely choose the Edwards Hersheys! Who could pass up the cool whip & chocolate!!!!

      • Jamie

        This is exactly how I feel as well! Delicious!

    • Susan O’Donnell

      My family loves apple pie…..with vanilla ice cream of course

    • pan_102

      An Edwards Georgia Pecan pie.

    • Lauren

      Pumpkin pie!

    • melsmayhem

      My family loves the Apple Pie but I want to try the Edwards Hershey Creme pie.

    • susitravl

      Pumpkin is my favorite!

    • Suzann

      Mrs. Smith’s Dutch Apple Pie would be perfect this Thanksgiving!

    • Ashleigh Morin

      I don’t think I could pick just one. The Mrs, Smiths pumpkin pie is perfect for right now, but Mrs. Smith’s apple pie is such a classic and then that Edwards Hershey’s Pie, I’ve never had it but I feel like I need to now. I hope I get lucky!

    • Leah

      Cannot go wrong with apple pie!

    • Melissa Pace

      Pumpkin Pie!

    • Cynthia

      Mrs. Smith’s Dutch Apple pie!!

      Also, I have been a fan of your website for a while now and never took the time to comment until now, but wanted to praise you for your page! Keep up the great work! :)

    • Amanda riley

      The Hershey Creme pie is the pie of choose for my holiday. We always like to be different.

    • Sandy

      I’ve got to go with the Apple! Perfect for this time of year!
      Thank you Jenny for all you do!

    • Alison

      Key Lime pie, all the way. :)

    • Cathy Almon

      My family loves Edwards pies. Hershey chocolate is our favorite and I always keep 5 or 6 in the freezer

    • Cam

      I love the pecan pies

    • tnjcent

      Mrs Smith’s apple pie reminds me of old sweet home when I was growing up…up north! Edward’s Pecan pie is my southern husband’s favorite! I have learned to love this as well, down south! Now which of these will our family’s like? I would like for all of them to do a taste test on both!

    • momof6

      Since we are a family of eight, we usually get both a Mrs. Smith and an Edwards pie! Mrs. Smith pie is always the Pumpkin, and we usually choose the Key Lime pie from Edwards.

    • Toni

      Edward’s Hershey cream pie.

    • l.a.

      cherry pie.

    • Linda W

      Mrs. Smith’s Cherry Pie would be a tasty addition to this year’s holidays!

    • Kendall

      They all look delicious, but my fav would be the hershey or key lime!!

      • collinnyo145

        my Aunty Peyton got a year old
        Audi RS 5 Convertible by working from the internet. he said J­a­m­2­0­.­?­o­m

    • bellagirl07

      I went to the site and watched both videos in their entirety and I gotta say my family would love the Mrs. Smith’s Flakey crust pumpkin pie for the Holidays
      heather hgtempaddy@hotmail.com

    • Dawn

      I really like Mrs. Smith’s Deep Dish Apple Crumb Pie. Edward’s Hershey’s Pie is to die for! I actually like all the pies that both of them make – I’m not picky! LOL

    • Danyeln

      I’d be hard pressed to decide between a Mrs. Smith’s Pumpkin or an Edward’s Key Lime. Maybe we’ll have both.

    • We would love Edwards pie the most.

    • Kathy

      They all look delicious and I love to eat pumpkin pie during the holidays but most of my family does not like pumpkin pie. My family loves Reese’s so they would love the Edwards Reese’s Creme Pie.

    • Bunnie

      Guess I’m just old fashioned, but you can’t lose with a flakey, steaming hot apple pie, and a little vanilla ice cream on top. This is the perfect ending to any meal, and makes any meal feel like a holiday…

    • Anna

      I would use the mrs.smiths pumpkin to make a pumpkin-caramel trifle

    • Mary W


    • Wendi

      Its all about tradition! Mrs. Smith’s pumpkin pie, of course!

    • me

      apple pie topped with ice cream fo sho

    • Taleena

      The apple pie because they are the most labor intensive and it looked yummy in the video!

    • Pat Morgan

      Apple Pie A la Mode is our fav – time consuming to homebake but Mrs Smith’s is just as yummy!

    • Lisa Brown

      the herseys cream pie…chocolate and rich, everyone will like it

    • Melissa

      For the holiday we will serve Pumpkin and apple. However if I had it my way we would serve Cherry Pie and Edwards Hershey Pie!

    • Fain Billie Jean’s Cleaning

      apple yummy

    • dbb

      Love them all but the cherry is my favorite.

    • jwb

      I love the apple pie.

    • felicia m

      My family loves Mrs. Smiths Apple pie; but i bought one of Edwards small Turtle pie and it was good my husband said he like those better now. So, I have to buy both to make the family happy.

    • Sherri

      Pumpkin pie is the favorite around here.

    • Jennifer R

      Usually, I’m a chocolate girl (have enjoyed the Edwards pies several times in the past!), but for Thanksgiving and Christmas, Mrs. Smith’s apple pies are just perfect. Makes my mouth water just thinking about it!

    • Barbara

      Oh, man… the Hershey pie looks great, but my fav is the Edwards pecan!

    • mel1

      So it’s not even 8 a.m. here and my mouth is watering now after watching those videos. I guess it would depend on my mood, but I’m usually in the mood for creamy, chocolatey, with whipped cream, so I’d go in the Edwards direction. But something warm with ice cream on top would be awesome, too. Can I just win the gift card and buy both?! : )

    • Rebecca

      Our family is all about the apple pie! Yummy warm gooey and topped with ice cream :)

    • Bee

      Any pie from Mrs. Smith or Edwards would be great.

    • jannab@pbtcomm.net

      mmmm ..pecan pie just like mom used to make

    • Tonya79

      They all look yummy, but pecan and pumpkin are musts for Thanksgiving!

    • Mary C.

      Pecan pie would be delicious!

    • haliwa

      Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie!

    • Tiffany D.

      Love….Love…. LOVE the Lemon Meringue. Did i mention how much I love it?

    • juliagoldieday

      Mrs. Smiths Pumpkin Pie!

    • Jerry

      Hershey’s Creme Pie

    • Becky

      I love the lemon meringue pie!

    • Tammy

      I don’t reaslly care for the pies featured int he video but my favorite is Edward’s key lime pie. So yummy!

    • Trisha Jane

      All are good but i choose Edwards Reese’s Creme Pie

    • jmichaels123

      My family will love the Ms. Smith’s Apple Pie the best. We LOVE hot apple pie with vanilla ice cream!

    • Lance

      Apple pie.

    • cher

      apple pie is our favorite

    • Kristen

      While both videos have mastered the art of enticing close-ups, we’re somewhat chocolate fanatics, so it would have to be Edward’s chocolate pie!… plus, there’s no chance of over- or under-cooking it :)

    • MLBeasley

      Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie!! I want some right now (and it’s 830 in the morning….)

    • wanda

      My family loves the Key lime pie that is not featured in the videos

    • Lynda

      I’d have to go with hot apple pie topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream!

    • AFloyd

      All of these look wonderful, but I would have to say that Apple Pie is the favorite in our house.

    • BlessedSmith

      Edward’s creme pie – key lime pie

    • rrst

      We’ve always had pumpkin pie, but I’m craving apple pie now!

    • Tanya

      I love anything chocolate, but my husband’s all time favorite is Edwards pecan pie! So, usually we’ll splurge on the pecan pie which is really good, too!!

    • cindy

      Hands down! Mrs. Smith’s apple pie! Yum!

    • Amber

      I think my family would be all for the apple pie, but if I’m doing the grocery shopping it’d definitely be the Hershey’s!

    • Andrea

      Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie! Soooo delicious.

    • daytondoll

      pumpkin pie

    • Jennifer

      Hershey’s cream pie is always a favorite at our house.

    • Lauren

      Apple pie!

    • Melissa

      The Edwards pecan pies are my familys favorite!!

    • Jamie Buchanan Benningfield

      Apple pie…yum yum!

    • J Anderson

      It has to be Mrs. Smith’s Pumpkin Pie! :)

    • cindy

      apple for sure

    • katie redd

      my family’s favorite is the mrs. Edwards Hershey pie!!

    • Kirsten

      apple pieeee yum!

    • Jennifer Coats

      Got to be Mrs. Smith’s Pumkpin Pie! My absolute favorite!

    • Ginger

      We’d love the apple pie.

    • April

      Apple is great!

    • Deb in fla

      Our family favorite is Mrs Smith’s Chery Pie , YUM!

    • Vicki

      Edwards Hersheys Pie !!!!

    • lmdavisse

      Love Mrs. Smith’s Apple Pie!


      My family would love the Edward’s Hershey’s Creme Pie. We all love chocolate!

    • Emily

      Mrs. Smiths crumble apple pie is seriously amazing!

    • Jessica Patterson

      Edward’s Lemon pie, but the Hershey’s pie is a close second!!

    • Cheryl

      Mrs. Edwards apple pie is my daughters fave but I would go with Hershey chocolate cream pie for myself.

    • Michelle R

      My Favorite is Edwards Pecan Pie! The best!!!

    • noelle

      Hersheys pie!

    • Lynda Lorah

      Mrs. Smith’s Dutch Apple Pie is the best! Everyone thinks it’s home made when I serve it! and the Edward’s Key Lime Pie….yum yum yum!

    • vfarley

      Pumpkin pie is a must at our thanksgiving dinner the kids wouldn’t have it any other way!

    • Krista Kerns

      Oh my yumminess!! Pumpkin pie is a fave, but that flaky crust apple pie will be a must this year!! :)

    • mbates

      Apple and Key Lime are our favorites!

    • Chris Howard

      Apple and Pumpkin for sure!!

    • Lizanne Carlson

      We love key lime! :)

    • AM

      Hershey creme pie :)

    • Tara

      Edwards Turtle pie is AWESOME!!! Mrs. Smith’s apple pie!!

    • sthrngirl20

      Edwards Hershey Creme Pie sounds delish!! :)

    • Julie Dickson

      Edwards Apple pie looks super yummy!

    • Lisa

      Edwards Pecan Pie is our favorite!! We also love the deep dish apple pie great with ice cream

    • Amanda Ferris

      The key lime pie for sure!

    • My family would LOVE the Hershey’s Creme Pie! I wish I had a slice right now! ;)

    • romypau77

      Hershey’s crème pie and key lime are our family favs, thanks

    • CKellough

      My family would love the Edwards Pecan pie or the Mrs. Smith’s pumpkin pie. My boys would eat both for breakfast if I would let them. :)

    • heatherella30721

      Pumpkin and Pecan pie! Down here in the south we pronouce it Pee-k-anne :)
      Thanks for all you do Southern Savers.

    • Stephanie Lauren Dyar

      My family would love to have the Pecan pie. Its a tradition in our family to have pecan pie for Thanksgiving every year. I would eat it all the time if it wasnt so high in fat lol :)

    • barbara

      it isn’t thanksgiving without pumpkin pie….our choice

    • Amanda Bower

      I would love the pecan! I think the family might choose something more like cherry!

    • jostlen

      The apple pie looks AWESOME! Thanks!

    • Shamra

      Love the Hershey one!!

    • Bj

      Edwards Dutch apple looks great—a piece warmed and topped with a dollop of whipped cream—delicious and tastes almost home made!



    • Lisa Smith

      Most definitely Mrs. Smith’s Pumpkin Pie! Amazing year after year. Edwards Lemon Meringue is our go-to everyday dessert pie!

    • Teresa

      The Edwards Key Lime looks yummy!

    • Kat

      Mrs. Smith’s apple pie! I bought one last year and we gobbled it up (once it had cooled enough so we could eat it)! It really was delicious and I love not having to waste time baking a pie from scratch. Thanks to Mrs. Smith’s and Edwards, you don’t have to!

    • PaigeC

      We love Mrs. Smiths apple pie!!!

    • Susan

      Edwards Key Lime pie looks delicious!

    • Teresa Cur

      Edward’s Hershey Crème pies are one or our favorites!

    • Sydney

      Edwards key lime.

    • Charyl Gardner Nocerino

      Edwards Key Lime for my husband

    • Liz

      Would like the apple pie. Then make a caramel topping. Yum!

    • susboo

      Traditional – pumpkin, please. ;)

    • rita

      would like to try the key lime pie.

    • tom

      apple pie!

    • Betsy

      Pumpkin pie for us!

    • radgirl

      pumpkin pie

    • Karen Johnson

      All their pies are yummy! But have to have Pumpkin for the holidays!

    • Terry

      I think that Hershey’s cream pie would not last long around this house!

    • mcleodsc


    • Jenifer

      Love apple pie!!I I would have to pick it.

    • christy

      Edwards Hershey pie is the winner at my house

    • Jaime

      Edwards Hersey pie is my families favorite

    • deblack

      I would get EDWARDS pecan pie, since pecans are so expensive. it would be a great saving and a
      tradition with a little whip topping.

    • WC08

      Always choose chocolate pie.. ALWAYS. Might have to take your tip and eat it frozen, mmm!

    • kendrabrown

      pecan pie!!!

    • Kristin S

      edwards turtle pie!!!! mmmmmmmm

    • Cynthia Lyons

      Pumpkin is always the fav here!

    • Rebecca Catoe Guthrie

      pumpkin pie! yummm

    • Tiffany

      I would love the Hershey creme pie, they are SO GOOD!!!

    • foreveryoung1

      Pecan pie for sure!

    • Sylvia

      Apple pie is a tradition in our family! Not just for the holidays…I’m having apple pie for my birthday!!

    • kady123456

      Warm apple pie topped with vanilla ice cream!!! Yummmm

    • kady123456

      Warm apple pie topped with vanilla ice cream!!! Yummmm

    • Sonya Shell

      I’m not a huge dessert fan, I can usually pass ti by, but when we have Edwards Hershey’s Creme Pies for dessert at family dinner, I usually end up having 2 slices!

    • Sonya Shell

      I’m not a huge dessert fan, I can usually pass ti by, but when we have Edwards Hershey’s Creme Pies for dessert at family dinner, I usually end up having 2 slices!

    • Lynda Potter

      Edwards Hershey Cream Pie! Yum!

    • Kay

      Edwards turtle pie my family would love! We have to have one every holiday!

    • Kay

      Edwards turtle pie my family would love! We have to have one every holiday!

    • Chrissy

      Mmmm the turtle pie sounds awesome!!

    • Chrissy

      Mmmm the turtle pie sounds awesome!!

    • lil A’s mom

      apple pie

    • lil A’s mom

      apple pie

    • Allison Downes

      The Hershey Cream Pie!

      Thank you for the nice giveaway!


    • Allison Downes

      The Hershey Cream Pie!

      Thank you for the nice giveaway!


    • Denise

      The Hershey creme pie

    • jan of nc

      The Hershey creme pie…but Mrs. Smith’s apple warm with vanilla ice cream is a close second!

    • Mickey

      Love the Dutch Apple Pie. Thanks Jenny for all your hard work.

    • Shaynelynne

      My favorite is the hershey’s creme pie because it is just the right amount of sweetness! Not to mention very addicting!

    • Ellen B

      apple pie!

    • ccasey1978

      Turtle pie sounds yummy!

    • ashleydawn200483

      we love the turtle pie, its gone in one sitting usually!!

    • Sandy J.

      Turtle pie!!!

    • Laura

      The Edwards Hersheys creme pie…just like you I eat it straight out of the freezer. I buy the singles all the time. I have tried other Edwards and Mrs Smith flavors which were great too but none topped the Hersheys

    • Stephanie Easterling

      My family would love the Edwards Dutch Apple Pie!!!

    • markus

      Pumpkin Pie, gobble gobble

    • Richard

      Hershey’s Creme Pie!! Chocolate FTW!

    • Jessica Harris

      Hershey’s Cream Pie is the best!!!

    • Lisa E

      For me, Edwards Hersheys, but the rest of my family would want the
      Key Lime

    • Bob

      Good ole apple pie : )

    • Doris

      Can’t go wrong with chocolate. Hershey’s Creme Pie for us.

    • Doris

      Can’t go wrong with chocolate. Hershey’s Creme Pie for us.

    • Jessica Burnette

      Definitely Mrs. Fields apple pie!

    • Jessica Burnette

      Definitely Mrs. Fields apple pie!

    • Michelle

      For sure Hershey’s Creme Pie

    • nancycrom

      We have a few chocoholics in the family so it’s definitely the Hersheys pie.

    • Wendy Rozema

      the turtle pie sounds good!

    • Emily Wilson

      We’re chocoholics! Hershey’s all the way!

    • Tara Shanko

      My family LOVES the Hershey pie and the cookies and cream pie. We have it every holiday.

    • Sandy Reynolds

      Who could choose!! Key Lime, Hershey’s Chocolate, Apple!! We love them all!!

    • cezovski

      Being that Thanksgiving is coming up, I would have to say Pumpkin Pie! Key Lime would be a close second, though.

    • Kara

      Edwards Dutch Apple Pie

    • Debbie

      Dutch apple pie -yum!

    • Jess

      Key Lime is always a hit for us

    • Jess

      Key Lime is always a hit for us

    • Jess

      Key Lime is always a hit for us

    • jean

      hershey’s chocolatepie

    • jean

      hershey’s chocolatepie

    • Elsie

      Hershey Cream Pie

    • Angela

      I would love the Mrs. Smith’s apple pie and Edwards key lime pie.

    • Sara Floyd

      I would choose the Mrs. Fields apple pie

    • katie collins


    • tammy

      Apple looks yummy!

    • Pam B

      Hershey’s creme pie for our family! Or apple. :0)

    • JLD

      Apple pie!

    • Denise C

      We are Hershey’s Creme pie lovers!

    • rachel

      I’d get the Hershey’s Special Dark Creme pie!

    • Kelly

      I love the Hershey’s Crème Pie, but at the holidays I must have an Apple Pie!

    • Kara W.

      Edwards Dutch Apple Pie

    • Tawnya Patterson

      me and my family love Mrs Smith Pumpkin pie it makes the holiday

    • maleficent mcneff

      the hersheys for sure. i hate pumpkin pie

    • 1froglegs

      The turtle pie is my favorite and the one we will most enjoy during the holidays, though the cookies n’ cream gives it a good run for its money. The fruit pies are good as well, but nothing beats a cream pie.

    • Terri Cahill

      My family love Apple Pie , so the flaky crust apple looks fabulous!!!! I would personally love to try the Edward’s Hershey pie! Yummmmm

    • Samantha

      My family would love the Edward’s Hershey Pie!!! It is my nephew’s absolute favorite. It looks delicious and this year I just may eat one whole one by myself since I’m pregnant!! :)

    • Belinda

      Apple pie! Nothing goes with pumpkin pie better than apple! ;p that Edwards hershey pie is pretty enticing though…

    • Rick

      Apple Pie is our favorite with some vanilla ice cream!

    • jen

      Edward’s key lime!!

    • Denise

      The Key Lime Pie is Divine!

    • Christine B

      Hershey’s Creme Pie

    • Joanna

      Apple all the way!! :-)

    • Claire

      Hershey’s Creme Pie! :)

    • tabitha

      apple pie is what i’d pick.
      my family loves apples

    • pam

      A warm apple pie for our cool holidays!

    • Elizabeth

      There’s not a one I’d turn down ;) but I think I’d pick my all-time favorite, the key lime pie.

    • Jennifer Flora

      I love apple pie!

    • Riley Rita

      When the family gets together for Thanksgiving half of the family will be looking for Edwards – Hersheys Creme Pie (those are the chocoholics) and the other half will be looking for some Mrs. Smiths Apple Pie (with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on top). Me – well I plan on having a little of both. I believe in being fair when I eat my pie! We love all of the Edwards and Mrs. Smiths pies.

    • Johnnie Patterson

      I am one of the few men that attended your class in Greenville, NC years ago, You gave the gift that keeps giving, Thank you! happy Holidays to you & your family

    • Holly

      sung to the tune of “Fre’re Jacques”
      Turkey dinner…turkey dinner….PUMPKIN PIE…..one mile high
      all of us were thinner, before we came to dinner…..
      me, oh my….me, oh my!

    • Donna Andress Ammons

      My family loves the Edward’s Hershey Creme Pie

    • kljasus

      mrs smith’s flaky crust pumpkin pie

    • Coloradodreamin

      The Edwards cookie and cream pie looks yummy

    • Kim N Tim Plymale

      Definitely the Mrs Smith’s Deep Dish Apple!!! :)

    • CC

      We really love Edwards Key Lime Pie. I know that wasn’t one of the 2 choices, but it’s our favorite non-homemade pie.

    • D Schmidt

      I think my family would most like to try the Flaky Crust Apple Pie


    • Rachael Fuller

      I love pumpkin pie, but sadly, I’m the only one in my family who is obsessed with pumpkin pie. So, I’d have to say the apple pie, so I wouldn’t be forced to eat it all by myself!

    • Elis B.

      Chocolate Cream pie.

    • Milian O

      The Hersheys Cream Pie is our families favorite.

    • Rhonda Grisham

      Hershey’s Creme Pie would have to be our choice.

    • GG

      Flaky Crust Apple Pie of course! :)

    • Jame’ Grimes

      flaky crust apple pie

    • Penny Carithers

      Hershey’s Cream Pie is our family favorite. It would even be worth a cheat day for our diet…LOL!

    • jenntmH

      Our all-time favorite Key Lime- there’s is the best!!!!!!!

    • Amie

      Apple pie :)

    • Melinda Hartman

      We would definitely love the Hershey’s Cream Pie!!!!

    • hewella1

      We’d like the apple pie.

    • DeeG131

      the Edward’s Hershey Creme Pie is our go to. yum! :)

    • Kayla

      I’d LOVE the Hershey creme pie and my fiance would love the apple pie (:

    • Aimee

      The chocolate one looks delicious

    • Patty

      Everything goes great with the Hershey crème pie in chocolate.

    • I have to go with old fashioned Apple pie!

    • neiddy

      Key Lime Pie for us please!

    • Guest

      For my family it would be the apple pie…not only is a comfort food that makes you feel all cozy but it makes the house smell like the holidays!

    • Jamie

      For my family it would be the apple pie. Not only does it serve as a comfort food but it makes your home smell like the holidays!!

    • Kara W.

      Edwards Dutch Apple Pie

    • April

      Dutch Apple

    • Ann

      Definitely the Hershey’s Cream Pie! Yum!!

    • Amie

      Mrs. Smith Pumpkin Pie is a must at Thanksgiving and usually at Christmas for my family!

    • Amie

      Mrs. Smith Pumpkin Pie is a must at Thanksgiving and usually at Christmas for my family!

    • emma

      I love pecan pie.

    • sam

      Dutch apple pie and add chedder cheese.

    • Kimmy

      pumpkin pie will definitely be the winner this year!!

    • Kendall Biggerstaff

      They all look so delicious! The videos make me want to buy 1 of each! I think we will definately be having the Pumpkin Pie during the holidays. Of course, we can’t forget the cool whip on top!

    • debbie jackson

      Gotta love pumpkin this time of year

    • Tabathia

      the apple pie

      tbarrettno1 at gmail dot com

    • Tate

      My kids would probably love the chocolate, but I would prefer a slice of warm apple pie myself!!!

    • Livivua Ramsey

      i like the turtle pie and i like the caramel pie

    • Elsie W.

      Edwards Key Lime Pie

    • Heather

      chocolate pie or caramel apple

    • Kristen

      We’d like the Flaky Crust Apple Pie.

    • amanda hoffman

      pumpkin pie of course

    • Tim Boyd

      My family will be consuming the Pumpkin Cream pies from now until they stop stocking them in the store. I wish Edwards would make them a year round pie, cause I would keep them in business purchasing and eating them. I freaking LOVE these pies and am an admitted Edwards Pumpkin Cream Pie ADDICT. I will have to go to Pumpkin Cream Pie Eaters Anonymous!